Showing posts with label Theory. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Theory. Show all posts

Band Evolution

I was reading up on the Dire Strait's history on wikipedia and listening to "Romeo and Juliet" and I noticed their member list was quite diverse. Subsequently the question came to my mind, "At what point is a band not the same because of shifting members?" In the Dire Straits example it's not too drastic because they did keep the lead singer(Mark Knopfler) and bassist(John Illsey) but at the same time the other two to four members over the years altered regularly. They might play the same songs and try to imitate the style but the real feeling of a musical group is with its soul members. When the members are switching around ever year or so can you really say you enjoy the Dire Straits or did you just enjoy the Dire Straits during their 1982-1984 era? Personally, I don't think a band should rightfully retain the name if it's not the true heart and soul of the group or the founding members. Realistically they can't just decided to change their name when they've gotten considerable success but I don't think they can really be considered that band without at least mostly original members so they retain that real emotion that the creator put into it. Maybe nothing can really change, it's a fact of life musicians move around and find other opportunities or have needs they need to fill and it's understandable, it just doesn't seem right to refer to a band as the same name when the current members barely resemble their predecessors ten years prior.

Stop stereotyping! You're not indie!

I've been dawning on this kind of realization that what I'm searching for isn't really getting my "hipster cred" and hanging out with my "indie" friends. Stereotypes aside, what really embodies the concept of "indie" has gone beyond alternative rock music. You could classify it by the hipster/scenester crowd and groups like Flaming Lips and Bloc Party but that's really only breaking the surface; that's really only the people who are either "posers" (god forbid we CALL them that) or the people that can't find or don't want a place in established mainstream groups so they discover these unknown bands and wear out-there clothes which eventually TURNS THEM INTO the stereotype of "hipster" and it's accepted.

In my view trying to be really Indie has nothing to do with that mindset. It's more of a longing to find those unique ideas that don't really get out into the world and interpreting and maybe promoting them yourself, going beyond just hipster music and fashion and encompassing the non-mainstream art, literature, films, opinions on current events, personal stories, and on occasion really out there concepts of fashion and design, all from the present and the past.

The problem with this is many people, like the hypocritical stereotype mafia, pretentiously oppose the stereotypes and reject anyone who LOOKS like they're taking up a specific stereotype. The problem with that is two fold: 1. these people who oppose stereotypes are essentially perpetuating them by acknowledging and opposing their existence 2. there's no way to AVOID these stereotypes anymore because they encompass just about everything sold. We are a society reared on capitalism and the sales managers of the world know it, they market everything based on specific demographics. The hippies have their food and clothing, the preps have their A&F and Hollister, emos and goths have hot topic, hipsters have their thrift stores and EBTM, so now no matter what you buy, wear, or listen to you're being entered into a stereotype whether purposely or accidentally.

In that strive to feel independent from the general views we seek out these strange ideas BECAUSE in every day life there's no escape from stereotypes. We're not TRYING to find our cliche, we're trying to find our own niche. That spot where we can feel comfortably accepted, viewed based on our personality and not our clothing store, and not constantly oppressed by that metaphorical stereotype mafia. Perhaps there is no more independent group, everything in existence has been classified, there is no such thing as miscellaneous and the only way to look unique is to change yourself and adapt day by day and, most importantly, to shake things up every once in awhile, oppose the norm, and express a new side to every thought process.

a real good life

after the renaissance, logic and "free thinking" have overcome just about every control society has had on the world. weve formed governments that represent the people, weve made life easier with technology, and created the middle class all of which made life "better" in most concrete aspects. but with the "improvements" came the dangers of powerful technology and eventually weaponry. besides that, capitalist empires have gotten our "representative" governments in a strangle-hold where they're no better than a socialist ideology with puppets for presidents. our political leaders dont listen to the populace, markets are becoming sudo-monopolies uncontrollable by the buyers, and institutions like the public education system create a linear lifestyle that puts a price tag on the "american dream." weve created a society where everything has a price and life is still a matter of survival. after thousands of years of societal growth, war, and reform we have improved nothing. for most there isnt a point in life where work stops and you begin enjoying life, its simply everyones goal to survive, make their own small fortune, and eventually improve through reproduction. the only improvement weve accomplished since the dark ages is in medicine. wars are just as terrible, life is just as hard, and governments just as oppressive.

which brings up the question: whats better, the simple, pious, agrarian life of the 1500s or the complex, capitalist empire that is the present day?

Wisdom vs. Knowledge

I've thought about the differences between being wise and being intelligent. I am reading a recent essay from Paul Graham entitled "Is It Worth Being Wise?" and he says that wisdom is knowing what to do in certain situations while intelligence is well....quite similar but there are some gray areas. I've always thought that wisdom was much different from knowledge or intelligence.

Wisdom is being smart about life, being reflective, and thinking about ways to explain everything. Wisdom can almost be thought of as a route to intelligence. When you have wisdom and use it you can be, for lack of better word, smarter and learn better; you grow from experience amentally and physically by retaining and applying knowledge. I like to relate wisdom to crew. Coach always says that rowing is "90% mental" and that you have to believe you can do better in order to do it. You may be strong, but that doesn't mean you can move a boat; you have to make every stroke stronger than the one before it. Wisdom is having the mentality and mental capacity to accomplish your tasks and respond to problems.

Intelligence, on the other hand, is knowledge of facts. You may know the physics of rowing and you know what good technique is but even the strongest person in a crew isn't the most contributing member, although it certainly helps. Just because you know a lot of facts and information doesn't mean you can be wise.